Remembering Rochester’s Regiment: Preservationists to save land in Virginia

By on December 3, 2018
Rochester’s 140th was a zouave unit, wearing fez caps and turbans, short jackets, baggy pantaloons and leggings, of an Algerian influence – a popular style at the time. Photo credit: Guy DeMasi.

Rochester’s 140th was a zouave unit, wearing fez caps and turbans, short jackets, baggy pantaloons and leggings, of an Algerian influence – a popular style at the time. Photo credit: Guy DeMasi.

“We are trying to save land in Virginia where boys from Rochester fought, and in some cases were captured, wounded, or killed”, said Tom Van Winkle, president of the land preservation and conservation group The Central Virginia Battlefields Trust (CVBT). Rochester’s own 140th New York Infantry fought on battlefield property the CVBT is now saving. “Although CVBT is based in Spotsylvania County, Virginia, we have a national following, and we want it to grow. We are in a race with time to save historic greenspace in this county where people from Rochester fought for the preservation of the Union and we are asking for your help,” said Chris Mackowski, professor at St. Bonaventure University and CVBT board member.

Since 1996, the CVBT has saved over 1,300 acres of “battlefield greenspace” from America’s bloodiest conflict — in the country’s bloodiest county – Spotsylvania – where over 750,000 soldiers fought and 110,000 fell in four battles in a mere 18 months. “Major newsgroups were publishing reports from ‘The Front’ regularly in Spotsylvania. Many Americans would know very well the names of the county’s battlefields – Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, ‘The Wilderness’, and Spotsylvania Court House – in addition to the local names of the roads, rivers, farms, that were fought over,” said CVBT board member Pete Kolakowski.  All four of those battlefields are ranked in the top ten deadliest battles of the Civil War.

The race with time to save this battlefield land has accelerated by the fact that Spotsylvania County, being just 60 miles from Washington, DC, has been one of the fastest growing areas in the United States. In Spotsylvania, the roads have been becoming choked with rising traffic congestion. Those same roads were also where massive armies marched, and bled over in the 1860s – a quandary for preservation and conservation groups.

Compare the rapid growth of Spotsylvania County with the hard reality that the underfunded National Park Service (NPS) owns just 1,500 acres of the 21,000-acre Spotsylvania Court House battlefield, or only 14 percent. Ironically, Spotsylvania Court House was the third bloodiest battle of the Civil War, lasting 13-days.

The target property the CVBT is now saving is part of that long-neglected battle in an area known as Myer’s Hill, where Rochester’s 140th fought.

The fighting at Spotsylvania Court House was also the costliest battle of Union General Grant’s famed and aggressive “Overland Campaign.” Grant’s Federal army suffered 50,000 casualties in 50 days slugging it through Virginia in 1864; it was a Presidential election year, and Abraham Lincoln needed military victories to be re-elected. In 1864 the warfare took on a more modern, and more desperate, feel.

By the time Rochester’s 140th New York attacked Myer’s Hill they had been in action for 9 straight days — losing 315 soldiers of 529. They were a hard-fighting, “zouave” unit, wearing fez caps and turbans, short jackets, baggy pantaloons and leggings, of an Algerian influence – a popular style at the time.

At 8 a.m. on May 14, the 140th New York zouaves and another regiment, attacked Rebel artillery and cavalry on Myer’s Hill. “Forward we go with bayonets,” said 140th Private August Seiser, “Under a rain of bullets.” Company B’s John Wetzel was hit in the left thigh, and George Dreschler in the hip. Tim Farrell of Brockport’s Company A took a Rebel bullet in the left foot. John Snyder of Churchville’s Company G was hit by a minie-ball in the finger.

The 140th take Myer’s Hill from the Confederates. Private Seiser rushed into the Myer House stating, “We reach the top, rush into the building. The rebels take to their heels and quickly we are the possessors.” The 140th set up a defensive position in Myer’s Hill orchard. They are relieved by a Federal brigade of about 900 men, which is later routed by a Confederate counter-attack of couple thousand. In this vicious Rebel assault, General Meade is almost captured while directing a Federal picket line. After a fierce Federal artillery barrage, Meade orders the 140th New York, and over ten thousand other Union troops, to attack and retake Myer’s Hill.  A Union soldier said, “The rebs were lying on the other side to avoid our shells which were hissing and exploding around the crest . . .”  Then the Federals attacked.  “When all was ready the bugle sounded the charge and we broke from cover like quarter-horses and with a volley of cheers mounted the hill. . . when they heard our cheers supposed a mighty force was coming and so they ran like the Devil.”

Historians have wanted Myer’s Hill preserved for a while. Chief Historian Emeritus of the National Park Service, Ed Bearss, said, “At Myer’s Hill, Grant was checked, but he goes back and takes it. The fighting for the hill results in a crucial two-day delay for his army.”

Noted Civil War and Spotsylvania author, Gordon Rhea said, “It is imperative that Myer’s Hill be saved to enable future generations to walk the ground and understand the momentous events that transpired there.”

Local resident and Spotsylvania Court House historian, John Cummings added, “I’ve been hoping for nearly twenty years now, to see this vital property preserved. The human interest stories relating to Myer’s Hill abound, and its preservation and interpretation will greatly enhance the understanding of the two week struggle at Spotsylvania Court House.”

CVBT pays fair market value for the historic land. They work with landowners who want to see their property saved for future generations to appreciate and learn about America’s vast history.

Private Seiser wrote after the Myer’s Hill battle, “Deadly tired we throw ourselves onto the wet ground . . . How is it possible to endure such strain and how long will it still last in this way?”

“We want to remember Rochester’s soldiers, and others, that fought at Myer’s Hill. By protecting this land it helps tell their story. CVBT is also saving greenspace along the way, and, simply put, we need your help to accomplish this,” said CVBT Executive Director, Elizabeth Heffernan.  She added, “CVBT’s administrative costs are low, at 14 percent; one of our mottos has been ‘Your green buys green.’”

To join or to donate to CVBT visit their website:

Provided information and photos

Soldiers of the 140th New York’s Company B. Photo credit: Brian Pohanka.

Soldiers of the 140th New York’s Company B. Photo credit: Brian Pohanka.